Reinventing Genres: Tips for Filmmakers

Genres offer filmmakers a blueprint for storytelling, but they can also become predictable if followed too rigidly. To stand out and captivate modern audiences, filmmakers increasingly experiment with genre conventions, blending or subverting established norms to deliver fresh and surprising experiences. However, breaking the mold comes with its own set of challenges. Here’s how you can navigate the evolution of genre to create something truly original.

1. Understand the Rules Before Breaking Them

Before subverting genre conventions, you need a deep understanding of them. Audiences have expectations tied to genres—romances promise emotional connections, while horror builds tension and fear. Knowing these tropes allows you to decide which to keep, tweak, or completely upend to create impactful surprises.

Actionable Tip: Study successful genre films to identify their core conventions. For instance, in horror, the “final girl” trope often symbolizes survival. If you’re creating a horror film, consider flipping the trope by making the “final girl” the antagonist.

2. Blend Genres to Add Depth

Blending genres is an effective way to challenge expectations while broadening a story’s appeal. Films like Get Out seamlessly mix horror and social commentary, while Shaun of the Dead combines comedy with zombie horror. These hybrids resonate because they respect the essence of each genre while delivering something unexpected.

Actionable Tip: Identify the emotional beats of your primary genre, then layer in secondary elements. For instance, a drama can incorporate sci-fi elements to explore human relationships in a futuristic setting, like Her did.

3. Subvert Character Archetypes

Audiences often anticipate specific character types within genres, such as the heroic protagonist in action films or the wise mentor in fantasy. Subverting these archetypes can result in compelling narratives. For example, Knives Out turns the classic whodunit genre on its head by revealing key plot points early, making the journey more about “why” than “who.”

Actionable Tip: Write character profiles for your leads and supporting cast, then challenge their roles. Can the villain be sympathetic? Could the mentor be unreliable? By defying expectations, you add complexity and intrigue.

4. Leverage Visual and Tonal Shifts

Genres often carry distinct visual and tonal markers—romantic comedies are bright and cheerful, while noir is dark and brooding. Playing with these elements can surprise audiences and enrich your narrative. For example, Parasite starts as a dark comedy but shifts into thriller territory, creating an emotionally charged experience.

Actionable Tip: Experiment with lighting, color palettes, and sound design to transition between tones or disrupt visual expectations. A colorful, vibrant world juxtaposed with a dark storyline, like in Jojo Rabbit, can create a striking contrast.

5. Balance Risk and Reward

Subverting genre expectations is a bold move, but it risks alienating audiences who expect familiarity. The key is to maintain a balance: innovate while staying true to the core emotional journey that the genre promises. For example, Mad Max: Fury Road redefined action films by focusing on relentless momentum while keeping the stakes and emotional arcs clear.

Actionable Tip: Test your story with trusted collaborators or small audiences. Gauge their reactions to ensure your subversions enhance the experience rather than confuse or frustrate viewers.

6. Reinvent Timeless Themes

While genres evolve, their core themes—love, fear, ambition, or survival—remain timeless. By addressing these universal themes in innovative ways, you can create works that feel fresh yet deeply relatable. A film like The Shape of Water reinvents the romance genre by pairing a mute woman with an amphibious creature, blending fantasy with profound emotional depth.

Actionable Tip: Start with a universal theme, then brainstorm unique ways to explore it. For example, instead of a typical hero’s journey, could your story revolve around a collective effort or an antihero’s quest?

7. Learn from Genre Masters Who Break the Mold

Many groundbreaking filmmakers have pushed genre boundaries, creating new storytelling paradigms. Directors like Jordan Peele, Bong Joon-ho, and Greta Gerwig challenge conventions without losing sight of the emotional core of their stories. Studying their techniques can inspire your own creative choices.

Actionable Tip: Analyze a few genre-bending films and dissect how they challenge norms. What tropes did they keep or discard? How did they maintain emotional resonance while experimenting? Apply these insights to your project.

Final Thoughts: Evolving Genre with Purpose

Subverting or blending genres isn’t about discarding traditions—it’s about evolving them to reflect contemporary sensibilities. By understanding the essence of genres and pushing their boundaries thoughtfully, you can craft stories that surprise, engage, and resonate deeply with audiences. The key is to innovate without losing sight of the emotional truths that make genres timeless.

Bolanle Media is excited to announce our partnership with The Newbie Film Academy to offer comprehensive courses designed specifically for aspiring screenwriters. Whether you’re just starting out or looking to enhance your skills, our resources will provide you with the tools and knowledge needed to succeed in the competitive world of screenwriting. Join us today to unlock your creative potential and take your first steps toward crafting compelling stories that resonate with audiences. Let’s turn your ideas into impactful scripts together!