Arizona Pastor Murdered in Gruesome Crucifixion; Suspect Confesses to Chilling Plot

A 76-year-old pastor from New River, Arizona, was brutally murdered and crucified in his own home in late April, in a crime that has shocked both the local community and the nation. Authorities say the suspect, Adam Christopher Sheafe, 51, confessed to the killing and revealed he had planned to execute at least 14 more religious leaders across the country as part of a self-declared spiritual mission.

Details of the Crime

Pastor William “Bill” Schonemann, known affectionately as “Pastor Bill” in his community, was found dead on April 28. His body was discovered on his bed, his arms stretched wide and nailed to the wall in a manner mimicking crucifixion. A crown of thorns, reportedly fashioned from desert plants, had been placed on his head. The scene was described by investigators as “blood-soaked” and “deeply disturbing”.

The Suspect and His Motive

Adam Sheafe was arrested days later near Sedona, Arizona, after allegedly attempting to target two more priests at the Chapel of the Holy Cross. In multiple jailhouse interviews, Sheafe admitted to the murder and described it as the first act in what he called “Operation First Commandment,” a plot to kill 14 pastors and priests whom he believed were “leading their flock astray”.

Sheafe told reporters and police that his motive stemmed from a radical interpretation of the Old Testament, claiming that Christian leaders who teach about Jesus are “misguiding their followers” and deserve to die. He expressed no remorse for the killing, repeatedly justifying his actions as obedience to what he believed was divine law.

“Because what I’m saying is, what you’re preaching is not what God said. It’s the opposite of what God said,” Sheafe stated in a televised interview.

Community Reaction and Investigation

The murder has left the New River community in mourning. Pastor Bill was remembered as a compassionate leader and friend, known for his generosity and his passion for helping others. Local authorities have described the crime as one of the most shocking in recent memory.

Sheafe is currently being held at the Coconino County Jail on unrelated charges, while Maricopa County prosecutors have charged him with first-degree murder. Investigators continue to probe Sheafe’s movements and any possible links to other religious leaders on his alleged “hit list.”

Ongoing Threats and Security Concerns

Law enforcement agencies nationwide have been alerted to Sheafe’s broader plan, and security has been increased at churches and religious institutions in multiple states. Authorities have not ruled out the possibility of accomplices or copycat threats, though Sheafe has claimed sole responsibility for the plot.

As the community grieves, the case has reignited discussions about religious extremism and the safety of faith leaders in America.